Skip to main content

25 Johnny Cake Hill Road

Old Lyme, Connecticut 06371

COMING SOON - NEW$1,659,000
Beds
4
Baths
3 | 1
SqFt
2,750
Acres
1.20
Year Built
1730
Matt Caiola

Matt Caiola

Luxury Real Estate Advisor

MCMATT CAIOLALUXURY PROPERTIES
Higgins Group Private Brokerage

Request a private showing and get Matt's read on price, condition, and next steps.

Call Matt
Pool2 FireplacesVirtual Tour

About This Home

An elegant and lovingly maintained antique colonial situated on 1.2 secluded acres near the Old Lyme Country Club. Recent updates include new landscaping front and back, new hardscaping around the pool deck, a new cedar roof, well tank, and a HVAC system including ductwork. The interior preserves the historic aspects of the home while graciously blending all the amenities of modern life. A formal living room and cozy library frame the front entryway, and lead to a large family room lined with walls of windows and French doors that bring in loads of natural light. Thoughtful classic architectural details throughout the home include wide-plank hardwood floors, custom built-in cabinetry, crown molding, and front and back stairwells. The cheery kitchen is placed conveniently off the dining area, again filled with more windows and French doors leading to the outside patio. With plenty of room for outdoor seating and dining, it is the perfect spot for entertaining friends and hosting family gatherings around the in-ground gunite pool and spa. A lush lawn beyond beckons for yard games and playing fetch with the dog. Upstairs are four distinctive bedrooms. The primary suite has an ensuite bathroom and walk-in closet. There is another bedroom with a second ensuite bath, and two more rooms that share a third bathroom.

Key Facts

City/Town
Old Lyme
Neighborhood
Johnnycake Hill
Property / Style
Single Family · Antique
Year Built
1730
Days on Market
0 days
Beds
4
Baths
3 full · 1 half
Living Area
2,750 sq ft
Lot Size
1.20 acres
Garage / Parking
5 total
Property Taxes
$13,714 / Annually

Market Snapshot

The Old Lyme Market

Single Family · trailing 12 months

Median Days on Market

39

22 active listings

Median $ / Sq Ft

$405

22 active listings

Sale-to-List Ratio

98.9%

89 sales

How this home compares

List Price

$1.66M

vs $779,000 median

2.1× the median

Price / Sq Ft

$603

vs $405 median

48.9% above median

Days on Market

0 days

vs 39 days median

39 days fresher than median

Based on 22 active and 89 closed sales (trailing 12 mo) of single family in Old Lyme. Source: SmartMLS · As of August 31, 2026.

Location

25 Johnny Cake Hill Road, Old Lyme, Connecticut

Property + 12 nearby

Estimate Your Payment

Estimated Monthly Payment

Rates: Freddie Mac PMMS via FRED
$10,225

per month

  • Principal & Interest$8,529
  • Property Taxes$1,143
  • Insurance$553
  • HOA$0

Estimates only. Actual rates, taxes, insurance, and HOA fees vary. Consult a lender for current rates.

Location

City/Town
Old Lyme
Neighborhood
Johnnycake Hill
County
New London

Residence

Property Type
Single Family
Style
Antique
Year Built
1730
New Construction
No/Resale
Living Area
2,750 sq ft

Schools

Elementary
Per Board of Ed
High
Per Board of Ed

Interior

Heating
Hot Air
Heat Fuel
Oil
Cooling
Central Air
Fireplaces
2
Appliances
Gas CooktopMicrowaveRange HoodRefrigeratorDishwasherWasherDryer
Basement
FullUnfinishedFull With Hatchway
In-Law Apartment
No

Exterior & Lot

Lot Size
1.20 acres
Zoning
RU40
Garage / Parking
5 total parking spacesPavedOff Street ParkingDrivewayPaved
Waterfront Details
Not Applicable
Water Source
Private Well
Sewer
Septic
Flood Zone
No
Pool
GuniteIn Ground Pool
Construction
Shingle
Color
Pink
Roof
Wood Shingle
Foundation
Stone
Exterior Features
Fruit TreesGuttersGarden AreaLightingFrench DoorsPatio
Lot Description
Lightly WoodedLevel LotProfessionally Landscaped

Listing & Financials

Property Taxes
$13,714 / Annually
Days on Market
0
MLS #
24201784
MLS Status
Coming Soon

Similar Properties

Homes with a close match in area, property type, and price.

Listed By

Susan Malan

(860) 767-5011

William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l

(860) 767-7488

This information is believed to be accurate, but without warranty.

The IDX display contains information sourced from SmartMLS, Inc. as of 8/31/2026. This information is provided for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing or leasing. Data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS, the listing broker, the listing agent, or Matt Caiola. Buyers and tenants should independently verify all information that matters to their decision.

Map locations may be approximate. Any offer of compensation, if applicable, is made only to participants of the MLS where the listing is filed. ©2026 Smart MLS, Inc. All rights reserved.

Data last updated on 8/31/2026 at 5:05 PM UTC.